The most expensive mistake is the quietest one. Wrong policy, right property.
It happens like this. You bought the place, lived in it, insured it as a home or a condo. Then you moved, kept it, and rented it out. The policy renewed automatically every year, so nobody thought about it. Now a pipe bursts, you file a claim, and the adjuster asks who has been living here.
A homeowners policy is written for a home you occupy. Once tenants live there, the carrier can investigate occupancy and deny the claim. Years of premiums, no coverage, and it is entirely avoidable with one phone call. If you are renting out a property that is still on a homeowners policy, stop reading and call us. That is the whole point of this page and everything below is detail.
The right policy is a landlord policy, technically a dwelling fire or DP-3 form. It costs roughly 15 to 25 percent more than homeowners on the same house, and it does three jobs that a homeowners policy does not: it insures the building as a rental, it covers the liability that comes with people living in a property you own, and it replaces the rent when a covered loss puts the unit out of service. That last one is why this policy exists. Your mortgage does not care that the kitchen burned.
Then there is 2026's new wrinkle, and it is the one almost nobody has priced in yet: SB 610 now stops the rent clock during a mandatory evacuation, whether or not your building is touched. Most loss of rent coverage was not designed for that. It is worth ten minutes of your attention before the next fire season, and it is the first thing we look at on a rental in this state.